Leif Erikson: Is the Viking explorer more important than Columbus?

The Greenlander Leif Erikson was the first European to reach America, 500 years before Columbus. But did it actually matter?
13 June, 2026
Leif Erikson pointing at America
Leiv Eirikson Discovering America, by Christian Krohg. Image: National Museum of Art, Architecture and Design, public domain

In 2022, the National Museum of Norway opened a brand new building in Oslo. Costing hundreds of millions of dollars and equally loved and loathed for its minimalist/brutalist design, the new home of the National Gallery became the centrepiece of a recent cultural blossoming in Norway’s capital.

The absence of a certain 1893 painting by Norwegian artist Christian Krohg sparked something of a scandal, however. The painting, an oil on canvas, depicts the moment the early medieval explorer Leif Erikson and his crew sight land, as related in the Norse sagas.

Though the painting was well-known and had been on display in the museum for decades, the celebrated artwork did not feature in the revitalised collection. In her justification of the decision, Department Director Stina Högkvist described the painting as a “colonialist image” that romanticised the European “discovery” of the Americas.

The controversy sparked a debate both in Norway and internationally about both the nature of culture and also Erikson’s achievements. As the first European to find America, 500 years before Christopher Columbus, could Erikson really be seen as the pioneer of the colonial movement of Europeans to the West? And if so, did that make him even more significant than the 15th-century Italian explorer?

Sculpture of Norse people
Silhouette sculpture of Norsemen above L’Anse aux Meadows National Historic Site, Newfoundland Canada. Image: Gordon Leggett / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=154758645

The heroic sagas

Our knowledge of Leif Erikson largely comes from the Norse sagas. While they were only written down centuries after the fact, the sagas contained oral tales and stories from the early medieval period when most of the events took place. In other words, each story usually contains elements of both fact and fiction.

Erikson features heavily in two of these tales: The Saga of the Greenlanders and The Saga of Erik the Red. As we learn from these two stories, Erikson’s father, Erik the Red, was banished twice – first from Norway and then from Iceland. In his efforts to escape his fate, Erik ‘discovered’ Greenland and help bring the first wave of Norse settlement.

Like his father, Leif was also an explorer and settler. In around 1000 CE, after returning from the court of Olav Tryggvason, Leif headed west. In one version, his ship is blown off course and he accidentally finds an unknown land. In another, he deliberately sails west. Regardless of exactly how he arrived, Erikson ‘discovered’ a new world, fertile with resources. He named it Vinland.

Turf house in Newfoundland
Exterior of reconstructed Viking house at L’Anse aux Meadows. Image: Eric Titcombe – https://www.flickr.com/photos/themuddler/9793189085/ CC BY 2.0

Historical confirmation

The area where Erikson first landed is believed to be the island of Newfoundland, on the eastern coast of Canada. Although the Norse exploration of this part of North America was often dismissed as mere tall tales, in the 1960s Helge and Anne Stine Ingstad discovered a possible Norse settlement at L’Anse aux Meadows in 1960, on the northernmost tip of Newfoundland.

Many artefacts from Norse societies back in Scandinavia were soon unearthed at the settlement, confirming its authenticity. Recent radiocarbon dating has also shown that the construction of the buildings dates from wood chopped down at the turn of the 11th century CE – just when Erikson was suspected to have travelled west. In other words, the basic fact of the sagas – that the Norse really did land on the outer reaches of the North American continent, is true.

If Newfoundland is Vinland, or at least part of Vinland, it is likely the Norse also explored at least some way further south, too. Birgitta Wallace, the former director for the L’Anse aux Meadows site, has argued the Norse likely travelled to at least the Bay of Saint Lawrence, and possibly further.

While the precise details of his voyage remain elusive, Erikson’s journey was certainly a remarkable feat of exploration. But does it also make him a colonialist, or place him at the vanguard of European expansion?

Map of Leif Erikson's journey to North America
The voyages of Leif Erikson, according to the sagas. Source: Dimitrios Karamitros / Shutterstock

A temporary home

It is certainly possible that Erikson – also known as Leif the Lucky – discovered Vinland by chance. Nevertheless, the fact that he was able to successfully journey from Newfoundland and back to Greenland and beyond shows he was a skilled navigator.

Leif was also surely a talented leader. The Greenlander guided the settlement’s first inhabitants from their homes in Norse societies further east to this western edge of the Viking world. There, he was able to build a home and investigate the potential of these unknown lands.

At the same time, we can also be fairly sure that Erikson did not ‘conquer’ or establish a permanent settlement in the New World. L’Anse aux Meadows had a rough lifespan of about two generations, or 50 years – a drop in the ocean.

A military invasion of the area would in any cases have been impossible. Newfoundland had already been inhabited for many thousands of years, of course. In the 11th century, the ancestors of the Beothuk, in particular, were a formidable local force. Despite their reputation for ferocity, the Vikings were would have been vastly outnumbered.

The sagas report initial friendly relations, but then at least one incident of serious aggression from a group of indigenous people. In all likelihood, the Norse there lived a difficult existence, always under threat. With a stay this brief and precarious, it is impossible to label Erikson a colonialist.

In contrast to Columbus

And here we see the key difference between the impact of Leif Erikson and Christopher Columbus. By island-hopping from Iceland to Greenland and then Newfoundland, the Norse had achieved a remarkable feat, accessing a completely unknown world that had been separated from the continents of Europe, Asia and Africa for thousands of years.

Yet in reality, they almost certainly did not realise just how striking this journey was. As Birgitta Wallace described, it was just the “next landmass along”. It is also worth noting that these particular Norse were visitors from a sparsely populated colony (Greenland) of a colony (Iceland). In sheer numbers, it was always unlikely they would settle permanently on the North American continent.

There are some signs that the Norse may have continued to trade west of Greenland for several centuries. Yet their influence on the people, fauna and flora of North America was likely minimal to non-existent. (You can read about Birgitta Wallace’s view of the relative importance of the L’Anse aux Meadows settlement on our Patreon page, here.)

It is also unclear if news of the Norse people’s exploits ever reached the rest of Europe. Yes, there are some rumours that Columbus himself journeyed to Iceland and heard of a rich and varied land to the west. Potentially, it could even have inspired him to cross the Atlantic. Yet it is also true that these stories have never been reliably substantiated.

Columbus’s impact, on the other hand, cannot be doubted. Though he was similarly unaware of exactly where he had landed, Columbus set in train a turn of events that would revolutionise global trade. Over the next 100 years, the Columbian Exchange would transform every continent in myriad ways. The Greenlander may have been the first European to set foot in the New World, but it was the Italian who changed everything.

Monument to Leif Erikson
Leif Erikson Monument, Humboldt Park Chicago. Image: Paul R. Burley, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=94250423

Leif’s legacy

Newfoundland itself would also have to be newly found, most probably by John Cabot in the early 16th century. In 1583, British explorer Humphrey Gilbert claimed it for the English. It would later become a key fishing area and an important staging post on journeys to the rest of North America.

That does not mean, of course, that Leif Erikson and his Viking Age companions would be the last of their kind to go west. Centuries after Erikson’s voyages to Vinland, Scandinavians began emigrating in large numbers across the same ocean to begin new lives in the United States and Canada.

For these freshly arrived immigrants, Leif Erikson became a heroic symbol of their history and culture. Like them, he had bravely crossed the Atlantic to find freedom. There are statues to him throughout the Midwest of the United States and Canada’s Prairie Provinces – all with a large Scandinavian ancestry today. In the United States, he even has his own day of celebration, 9 October.

But despite this influence, it is extremely hard to see Erikson himself as a colonialist. Neither, of course, did he ‘discover’ North America. As the First Nations people of Canada, Mexico, and the United States could testify, it was already found.

As for the painting, Högkvist eventually backtracked on her comments after a huge outcry and the museum issued an apology. Today, it hangs in a prominent place near the entrance to the main gallery.

A version of this article was originally published on our sister website, The Viking Herald.

Sign up to receive The Age of Exploration newsletter once a fortnight.

Jonathan Williamson

Jonathan is an editor at the Viking Herald and a gigantic lover of history. Born in Australia, he studied and worked for several years in Oslo, Norway, before returning back Down Under to settle down his family.

Don't Miss

Three caravel ships at sea

The great explorer: What made the caravel so special?

The caravel is an iconic ship. Used in the fleets of both
Cloudberry on marshland

Seaweed and cloudberries: How the Vikings solved scurvy

When European explorers set out to explore all corners of the world