The history of Arctic exploration is littered with stories of foiled ambition, gruesome deaths and people on the brink of madness. Yet perhaps more than any other, the tale of CF Hall highlights how the most extreme of environments can lead to the most extreme behaviour.
Captain Hall was an irascible, eccentric and obsessive American who spent years living with the Inuit of the Arctic Circle as he bid to become the first person to reach the North Pole. The person suspected of causing his death was a meticulous German scientist who could (allegedly) bear him no more.
This is the story of the Polaris expedition, and a murder case that took 97 years to solve.
An irresistible obsession
Details of Charles Francis Hall’s early years are scant. It is thought he was born into an unremarkable Vermont (or possibly New Hampshire) family in approximately 1821. A high-school dropout, Hall initially worked as an apprentice to a blacksmith.
In his early twenties, Hall married a young woman, Mary Anne, and started a family in Cincinnati. There, he initially got into the engraving business. Clearly restless and entrepreneurial of spirit, Hall later also published his own newspaper, the Cincinnati Occasional.
At some point in this period, Hall began to develop a keen interest in Arctic exploration. This was the era of the John Franklin expedition, which made headlines across the world and caught the imagination of many a would-be adventurer.
When Franklin and his ships mysteriously disappeared in the ice, explorers from across Europe and North America set out to hunt them down. Hall read everything he could on the subject, and by the early 1850s had become utterly fixated on the Arctic.

Helping hands
Despite a complete lack of sailing experience, Hall attempted to raise money for his own expedition. Unsurprisingly, he struggled to get the necessary funds. In 1860, however, Hall was able to gain passage on a voyage north led by Captain Sidney Budington. The ship made it as far as at Frobisher Bay on Baffin Island, where the crew were forced to winter.
In contrast to many previous Arctic explorers, Hall was exceptionally curious about the habits of the Inuit. His main hope on the voyage was to contact local people and learn how they were able to survive in the far north.
As luck would have it, an Inuit couple, Ipirvik and his wife Taqulittuq, boarded the ship at Frobisher Bay. Both spoke English – it turned out a whaling captain had taken them to England in the 1850s, where they had enjoyed a dinner with Queen Victoria and Prince Albert before returning to Baffin Island.
In the following days and weeks, Ipirvik and Taqulittuq (also known as Ebierbing and Tookoolito) would show Hall the ways of the Inuit – how to move through the ice, shelter from the freezing temperatures and find sources of food. They also regaled the American with tales of voyages past, including ships that long ago had brought coal, bricks and iron.
Hall soon realised this particular story must refer to the Frobisher expeditions, when the English sailor Martin Frobisher had travelled to the Arctic and attempted to mine for gold. Hall would remain with the Inuit for two years, and was able to retrieve some relics from Frobisher’s stay in the region.
Striking out
When Hall returned to the United States, Ipirvik and Taqulittuq also came with him and lived for a period in Connecticut. In the meantime, Hall wrote an account of his voyage, published as Arctic Researches and Life Among the Esquimaux. During its composition, however, Hall fought bitterly with his editor William Parker Snow, a fellow Arctic explorer.
Hall was soon planning a second trip with a larger ship of his own. This time, he was determined to find out the fate of the Franklin expedition. Hall’s attempt at organising a major expedition fell short, mainly due to a lack of funds. Hall’s deteriorating relationship with Snow – who was to be second-in-command – was another complication.
Hall was eventually able to commandeer a smaller vessel, the whaler Monticello. The ship departed in July 1864 for King William Island in the Arctic Archipelago. There, Hall was able to retrieve some remains and artefacts from the Franklin expedition and speak to the Inuit about what they recalled of the British explorers. Many years later, this testimony would help finally identify the location of Franklin’s ships.
By this time, Hall was an experienced adventurer, and had little trouble surviving in the north. Yet this was a gruelling and extremely challenging five-year expedition. Hall’s interpersonal skills continued to be a source of immense difficulty, as he struggled to retain control of his crew.
In Repulse Bay in July 1868, a whaler named Patrick Coleman began challenging Hall’s authority. Hall was further irritated by Coleman’s attempts to speak to the Inuit – a perceived impingement on Hall’s personal domain. After a fierce argument, Hall returned to his quarters, picked up a revolver, and promptly shot Coleman dead.
The incident cast a dark pall over the expedition. When two whaling ships arrived at the bay a few days later, the remaining four whalers deserted and sailed away. Hall, of course, stayed with the Inuit.
When he finally returned to the US, Hall justified the act on grounds of self-defence. He was never charged for the killing.
The Polaris sets sail
In 1871, CF Hall finally received his big break. After years of struggling to finance voyages to the north, he was awarded a grant of USD 50,000 from the US Congress to command USS Polaris on an expedition to the North Pole. The crew of 25 included a certain Emil Bessels, who was appointed ship physician and chief of scientific staff.
Born in Heidelberg, Germany, Bessels was an accomplished and highly educated man, with expertise in zoology and entomology. After taking part in an earlier German expedition to the Arctic in 1869, Bessels had later worked as a doctor in the Franco-Prussian War. Bessels earned a public commendation from the Grand Duke of Baden for his service in the conflict.
The Polaris, however, struggled to make headway against the thick pack ice of the far north. On 10 September 1871, Hall made the decision to weigh anchor for the winter at Thank God Harbour in northern Greenland. The plan was to spend several months exploring the local area before making a push for the North Pole in the spring. By this point, however, feelings were running high.
Four members of the crew had already deserted prior to departure in Brooklyn. As the ship headed north, Hall had clashed dramatically with Bessels, with the latter refusing to accept the American’s authority over the scientific staff. Meteorologist Frederick Meyer, a German-born US sergeant, had been threatened with being shackled, while a boiler was thrown overboard following a heated dispute.

Death of an explorer
As winter took its grip at Thank God Harbour, tensions began to mount even higher. Hall accused the ship’s sailing master Sidney Budington of being an alcoholic and raiding the ship’s stores. And when Hall passionately argued they should head for the North Pole in the spring, Budington and Bessels insisted it would be better to cut their losses and return home. In their eyes, the solid ice of the Arctic Ocean was too big a barrier to overcome.
In mid-October, still in the depths of winter, Hall set out to explore the surrounding area with Ipirvik, his Inuit companion. They were accompanied by another Inuit, Hans Hendrik, who had already taken part in two previous Arctic expeditions. After struggling to make headway, the group returned to the ship on 24 October. Happy to be back at camp and apparently suffering from exposure, CF Hall gratefully received a warm cup of coffee. It did not have the desired affect, however – the American captain became violently sick immediately after drinking it.
As an experienced physician, Bessels was tasked with caring for the ailing commander. Over the next few days, Hall suffered debilitating bouts of stomach pains, vomiting, dizziness, dehydration and dementia. At one point, he confided to the assistant navigator George Tyson that he believed someone was trying to poison him.
At times, Hall improved and appeared close to recovery. But on 8 November 1871, the pain struck again. This time, despite all of Bessels’ efforts, Captain Hall could not hold on. The man who had made it his life’s mission to reach the North Pole was buried in a shallow grave at Thank God Harbour, around 500 miles south of his final objective.
Cut adrift
Several crew members later expressed their relief at Hall’s death. Yet it did not change their basic predicament – the Polaris was trapped in the ice for the foreseeable future. Over the next few months, Budington, now in overall command, apparently turned further to drink. With coal stores dwindling and the escape route uncertain, morale sank even lower.
In June 1872, Tyson and first mate Hubbard Chester decided to make a push for the Pole in a whaleboat. Just a few miles from the ship, however, the boat was crushed by pack ice. They soon set out again with another whaleboat and a collapsible.
Yet within days, Budington sent Ipirvik to retrieve that party – Polaris had finally found open water and it was time to return home. Frustrated beyond measure, Tyson nevertheless abandoned the two boats and headed back to the ship. The North Pole would have to wait.
The ship gradually inched its way south. But on 15 October 1872, the Polaris ran aground on a shallow iceberg close to the Humboldt Glacier. The next morning, a group including Tyson, Meyer and several Inuit was out on the ice when the pack ice began to break up and the Polaris came free. Although the men on the ice signalled to the ship to wait for them, Budington and the rest of the crew sailed off, leaving them to their fate.

The long way home
Remarkably, both parties would survive. Stuck on an ice floe with no realistic means of escape, Tyson’s group must have felt their situation was hopeless. In November, some of the men went on a tremendous eating binge, devouring a large chunk of the remaining food.
Yet the Inuit were in their element. Ipirvik and Hendrik soon built igloos to provide shelter and began hunting seals – a crucial source of sustenance above the Arctic Circle. The small group would drift on the floe for six more months, covering a distance of some 1,500 miles. On 30 April 1873, they were finally picked up by the whaler Tigress off the coast of Newfoundland.
The going was no easier for Budington and the men on the Polaris. The crew were also desperately low on supplies, having jettisoned bedding, clothing and food when the Polaris was stuck on the iceberg. With the coal stores also nearly gone, Budington deliberately grounded the ship near the Etah settlement in northern Greenland.
Here too, it was the Inuit that helped them survive the winter. The local people of Etah provided the European and American crew with food and shelter. The following year, the crew built two boats from the carcass of the now-crushed Polaris and sailed south. In July 1873, they were finally rescued by another whaler, the Ravenscrag.
Absence of evidence
By this time, Tyson and his party had already returned home, and the US Navy had ordered an investigation into Hall’s death. There were some clear grounds for suspicion.
Tyson recounted Hall’s claims he had been poisoned and also detailed his the symptoms of his illness. Later, it also became clear that some crew members had removed entries from their journals that covered the time when Hall had died.
Yet when Budington and the other crew members returned home, they strongly disputed Tyson’s account. Instead, Bessels asserted Hall had likely fallen ill from exposure, and noted he had been suffering from paralysis.
With no body to examine and no convincing evidence of foul play, the board concluded that Hall had died from natural causes. In their report, they stated that Bessels had done his best under the circumstances to keep the American captain alive. For now, the truth would remain hidden.

Cold case murder?
In the late 1960s, the writer Chauncey C. Loomis began work on a biography of CF Hall. Intrigued by the controversial circumstances of his death, Loomis applied for a permit to dig up Hall’s body for an autopsy. The writer travelled to Thank God Harbour in 1968 and exhumed the body, which had been preserved in the permafrost.
The tests produced a shocking finding. Samples taken from Hall’s bone, fingernails and hair showed the unfortunate captain had received large doses of arsenic in the last two weeks of his life. If correct, the results appear to point towards deliberate and cold-blooded murder.
The results were also consistent with the symptoms described at the time: stomach pains, vomiting, dehydration, stupor and mania. The fact that Hall had complained that his coffee had been too sweet was another reason for suspicion – arsenic often produces a sugary taste.
There was also a clear motive – several members of the expedition had complained bitterly of Hall’s leadership and there were indications that a mutiny was already on the horizon. Several, including Budington and Meyer, could be considered worthy of accusation.
Emil Bessels, however, remains the prime suspect. As the physician, Bessels had constant access to Hall before his death. Remarkably, he was also a rival in love.
Prior to the expedition, he had competed with Hall for the attention of Vinnie Ream, a talented artist who had just completed a sculpture of Abraham Lincoln for the Capitol. Could Bessels have taken revenge in the lawless realm of the Arctic?
In reality, we cannot know for sure. Emil Bessels was never charged, and went on to work successfully for the Smithsonian Institution for several years before moving back to Germany. The physician died of a reported stroke in Stuttgart in 1888, aged 40.
CF Hall’s own death remains a matter of dispute. We will also never know if the American explorer could have made it to the North Pole. Today, despite his pioneering work alongside the Inuits, Captain Hall remains little more than a footnote in the history of Arctic exploration.
Recommended reading: A Fabulous Kingdom, by Charles Officer.
You can also access a copy of CF Hall’s book online at archive.org: https://archive.org/details/arcticresearches00hall
